Album Review: Alanis Morissette – Good Weather for Immaculate Conception
Alanis Morissette is hardly the first name that springs to mind when you think of Christmas albums, which makes this rather an intriguing left turn. Having spent decades delivering some of alternative rock’s most emotionally charged songwriting, from the angst-ridden brilliance of Jagged Little Pill to the more reflective territory of her later work, Morissette is now embracing the festive season with Good Weather for Immaculate Conception. Released via Virgin Music, it’s her first full-length Christmas album, bringing together a collection of seasonal classics, a few familiar festive favourites and two original compositions. There’s also an unexpectedly eclectic guest list, featuring Brandi Carlile, Steve Martin, Martin Short and Joy Oladokun. Is it a Christmas dinner party to remember, though?
Kicking off with a classic Christmas carol, Alanis keeps it traditional and simple with O Holy Night, before moving to her own track, To an Empath at Christmas Time – which is a decent pop rock track, appealing to those who feel the need to distract from their pain by performing to, and looking for approval from others – “You don’t need to perform peace for us”. Another carol, What Child Is This? follows, with Julian Coryell on guitar, Alanis really shows off her vocal power in this one, whilst the cover of John Lennon’s Happy Xmas (War Is Over) is excellent (but obviously never going to be a patch on the original). I didn’t love Little Drummer Boy, didn’t think her vocal tones worked well on the track, which will forever be Bing Crosby, whilst Beautiful Star of Bethlehem sees Steve Martin on the banjo and Brandi Carlile assisting in the vocals, and was a fine rendition, as was Alanis’ take on Ave Maria.
New track Christmas on the Dancefloor provides a kind of heavy pop rock track, which sounds weird, but I really enjoyed it. A simple yet elegant rendition of Joni Mitchell’s River is followed by Momma Mary is a duet with Amythyst Kiah – a cover of Roger Whittaker’s retelling of the Nativity story, through asking direct questions to Mary about emotions, fears, and the journey. Carol O Tannenbaum features Trans Voices providing chorale support and covers both (original) German and the English translation, whilst Wham’s Last Christmas is somewhat a karaoke version (which probably is a good idea, as any artistic interpretation would likely fall flat). Penultimate (carol) track Silent Night is a simple retelling of the classic, though. Joy Oladokun definitely gives the track a little extra. Finally, we are lucky to have Martin Short adding his unmistakeable voice to Merry Christmas in what is probably my favourite cover of the album.
Good Weather for Immaculate Conception is a decent Christmas album of covers with two original tracks hidden amongst the reeds. The covers are, in the main, true to the originals and good enough, but honestly I’ve heard 1000’s of Christmas song covers, and seldom, if any, top the original/established rendition– and so, for me, it feels somewhat like unnecessary padding around what could have been a double-side Christmas single.
